Field notes · November 17, 2026 · By Nick Palasz
How to evaluate a business to buy:
a buyer's checklist.
To evaluate a business to buy, start with what it really earns for an owner, check that the income is real, then ask how much of it walks out the door with the current owner. Price comes last. Most small businesses are valued as a multiple of earnings, so getting the earnings right is most of the job.
1. Work out what the business really earns
For an owner-run business, the usual number is seller's discretionary earnings (SDE): profit plus the owner's salary and perks, plus one-off costs. Larger businesses with a management team are usually measured on EBITDA. Ask for about three years of profit and loss statements and tax returns, and rebuild the number yourself. See SDE, defined.
2. Verify the income
| Check | What you compare | What a gap can mean |
|---|---|---|
| Tax returns vs P&L | Revenue and profit on the returns against the owner's statements | Cash not reported, or numbers dressed up for the sale |
| Bank statements vs P&L | Deposits month by month against reported sales | Sales that never reached the bank |
| Add-backs | Every expense the seller wants added back to earnings | Real running costs labelled as personal or one-off |
| Customer list vs revenue | Who pays and how much | Revenue that depends on one or two accounts |
| Trend | Month by month for the last two to three years | A strong year propping up a falling business |
If the seller will not share returns or bank statements after an LOI, that is your answer. Use an accountant for the full quality of earnings work on anything you are serious about.
3. Ask how much of it depends on the owner
Who brings in the customers? Who knows how to do the work? Who do suppliers call? If the answer to all three is the owner, part of what you are buying leaves at closing. That is not always a dealbreaker, but it should change the price, the transition period, or both.
4. Look at the customers
- Concentration. If one customer is a big share of revenue, losing them after the sale changes everything.
- Recurring revenue. Contracts and repeat customers are worth more than one-off jobs.
- Contracts that transfer. Check whether key contracts and the lease can move to a new owner.
5. Then think about price
Small owner-run businesses are commonly valued at a multiple of SDE, with the multiple moving up for clean books, recurring revenue, growth and low owner dependence, and down for the opposite. Asset value and comparable sales are cross-checks. A valuation is an estimate; the price is what you and the owner agree, and the terms matter as much as the number. Try our business valuation calculator for a first range, and read how to value a small business.
Red flags that should stop you
| Red flag | Why |
|---|---|
| Books the seller will not share | You cannot price what you cannot see |
| Earnings mostly made of add-backs | The real business may barely make money |
| One customer, one supplier or one employee holding it up | One phone call can undo the deal |
| Revenue falling and a story about why next year is different | You would be paying for the story |
| A lease that cannot transfer | The location may not come with the business |
How many businesses you will look at
Most buyers evaluate far more businesses than they buy. In one buy-side program we ran, 188 owner conversations led to 3 signed letters of intent. Getting those conversations is its own job:
| Outreach program | Owners emailed | Replied | Reply rate | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| UK business owners, for a brokerage | 15,569 | 447 | 2.9% | 70 seller calls |
| Software founders, for one acquirer | 11,375 | 534 | 4.7% | 86 owner calls |
| Owners for a buy-side fund | 35,000 emails sent | 188 owner conversations, 3 signed LOIs |
About 3 in 100 owners replied to a first outreach, and owners of companies with 5 to 10 employees replied more than twice as often as those with 21 to 50. All the numbers: owner outreach benchmarks. Once a business passes your checks, the next step is a letter of intent. If you need more owners to evaluate, see our deal sourcing page or ask for a free sample list of 25 verified owners in your market.
Questions buyers ask
How do you evaluate a business to buy?
Rebuild what it really earns for an owner, verify the income against tax returns and bank statements, check how much depends on the current owner and a few customers, then price it as a multiple of those earnings.
How do you verify income when buying a business?
Compare the owner's profit and loss statements to the tax returns and bank deposits for the last few years, and question every add-back. An accountant can do a full quality of earnings review.
How do you know if a business is worth buying?
If the verified earnings support the price at a sensible multiple, the business does not walk out with the owner, and no single customer or supplier holds it up.
Want outbound run for you?
We build the owner list, send from your name, answer every reply and book the seller calls. $850 launches your first campaign and your first qualified seller call is guaranteed.
See how it worksNot ready to talk? Get a free sample list of 25 verified owners in your market. No call needed.
Get the field notes
Leave your work email. New notes go out when they are written, not on a schedule.
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
